PSG Energy is your strategic energy cost partner
The $578K Water Bill Mystery That Stumped Everyone
The Challenge: The Vanishing Profit Margin
A regional property management company watched helplessly as water costs at their premier office complex skyrocketed 340% over 18 months. Tenant complaints poured in. NOI plummeted. The property went from star performer to problem child.
The panic: With lease renewals approaching, tenants threatened to relocate due to escalating utility costs.
"Our water bills went from $12,000 monthly to over $40,000. We had no explanation for tenants, and our NOI was getting destroyed." - Regional Property Manager
The Investigation: Following the Money Trail
While the utility company insisted "usage has increased," our forensic analysis told a different story. We examined 36 months of billing data, internal metering protocols, and utility service records - uncovering a systematic problem hiding in plain sight.
The smoking gun: Metering irregularities that created a cascading billing error affecting the entire complex.
The discovery: The utility had been double-billing for common area water usage while simultaneously charging individual tenants for the same consumption.
The Detective Work
Phase 1: Billing archaeology revealed inconsistent meter readings dating back 24 months
Phase 2: On-site metering audit discovered faulty allocation protocols
Phase 3: Utility refund analysis exposed systematic overcharges across multiple service categories
The breakthrough: Found evidence that utility's new billing system had misclassified the property's meter configuration, creating duplicate charges.
The "Impossible" Recovery Battle
The utility's position: "Our billing is accurate. No refunds available."
Our strategy:
Documented systematic billing errors with irrefutable evidence
Leveraged utility relationships to escalate beyond customer service
Presented regulatory compliance issues that motivated quick resolution
Negotiated comprehensive settlement covering all affected periods
The Stunning Resolution
$578,000 immediate refund covering 24 months of overcharges
10% ongoing annual savings through corrected billing protocols
Tenant relations restored with explanation and partial credits
Property value protected through stabilized operating costs
Timeline: 89 days from investigation start to refund check deposit
The Transformation
"PSG didn't just get our money back - they saved our property. Tenants went from threatening to leave to signing lease extensions." - Regional Manager
The ripple effect: Corrected billing attracted new tenants who had been scared off by previous high utility costs.
The Hidden Pattern
Post-recovery discovery: Similar billing errors found at 3 other properties in the portfolio, resulting in additional $240K in recoveries.
The lesson: Water billing errors are often systematic, affecting multiple properties under the same utility provider.
The Competitive Advantage
With stabilized utility costs, the property could offer competitive lease rates while maintaining healthy margins - turning a crisis into a market advantage.
Why This Case Matters:
Shows how utility billing errors can destroy property NOI
Demonstrates the importance of forensic bill analysis vs. accepting utility explanations
Proves that "accurate" utility billing often isn't accurate at all
Illustrates how energy cost recovery protects property values and tenant relationships
What billing mysteries are hiding in your property portfolio?
